Avidyne vs. Garmin - Fight!

I spent some time today learning about the latest offerings from Avidyne in their glass panel products. I have wondered for a while what they might do to combat the powerhouse that is Garmin. Garmin has quickly made in-roads with their G1000, even displacing Avidyne in what I consider Avidyne's flagship deployment platform - the Cirrus SR22.

Currently, if you want to give Cirrus as much money as possible for an SR22 you will get a Garmin, not an Avidyne. Additionally, even when you do buy an Avidyne-equipped airplane Garmin STILL makes money - the Avidyne is always installed with Garmin radios and GPS units. I think Avidyne aims to fix that with their new FMS900w system.

This new system replaces the Garmin radios in the installation with a keyboard equipped "remote pad" for entering waypoints, freqs, etc. It even has a QWERTY keyboard - imagine that! The system also includes updated main displays. These now support synthetic vision (much like you'd see in a flight sim) and night vision cameras.

They also redesigned the UI - one of the big places Avidyne sets itself apart from Garmin. Avidyne actually cares about ease-of-use which is so critical for an in-flight software system. This is evident in the new setup with - just like their old system - a near-total lack of sub-menus and other "hidden" options. This means less time fumbling through the "pilot's guide" in-flight and less brain power devoted to simply operating your gear.

They also re-thought the "reversionary" mode to deal with a failed display. They re-thought it by getting rid of it completely. You simply configure each screen the way you want it - turn the MFD into the PFD with a button press. Want to see the engine instruments on the PFD for a moment - press a button. This means that if you are operating with a failed screen you can still access all capabilities, not just some of them as in the G1000.

The only place I still see Avidyne behind the curve is in the autopilot department. I've yet to see a GA autopilot that bests the Garmin GFC 700 (GFC 700 video).

Of course, to catch-up with Garmin they need to get this system out into the wild - and in large numbers. That is probably a much tougher chore than the entire tech development side of the equation.

Here's a quick rundown of the new Avidyne:

Comments

Hamish said…
Much as I would probably like the Avidyne in real life, the problem it faces is that the G1000 is everywhere: I can fly 172's, 182's, Cirruses, and lord knows what with almost identical G1000 installations (and I do). As irritating as it might sometimes be, the G1000's become common currency in smaller GA planes, and threatens to become standard: if given a choice between G1000 and Avidyne equipped rentals, I'll probably always go for the familiar...
January 5, 2009 at 3:12 PM
Unknown said…
Well I guess it's game on just as you wanted/predicted. Avidyne's announced their autopilot. On their website, it looks like they have a division to do this stuff.
April 17, 2009 at 6:35 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Updating data on the Garmin Perspective system

Image
After changing from the Avidyne system to the Cirrus Perspective (G1000) system, I had to relearn an important part of owning an airplane: how to update all the data the systems use. There's even more data in the Perspective, including AOPA directory data and more charts. In this walkthrough, I make use of the Jeppesen app for Apple OS X: JDM .  It has worked well for me, though I did need to call Jeppesen when I first set this up to get my subscriptions fixed up.  They gave great customer support when I did. The process starts (optionally) by hooking up a ground power unit (GPU).  In the case of the Cirrus, you can certainly do this without it, but I tend to hook it up just to be sure.  The systems draw about 8-10amps while updating, but you won't generally have the power on for long.  One tip I've read: power up the GPU before plugging it into the plane, at least for the one I bought.  That saves the plane from seeing any power spikes that might have occurred when t
Read more

G1000 transistion training - emergencies - final flight

Image
For the final flight in my G1000 transition course we focused on failure scenarios. Not the "engine goes POOF" kind but the avionics kind. Normal situation This picture shows what the 2 Garmin screens show in a normal (non failure) situation. You can see we have 2 screens - the left PFD focusing on flight performance (airspeed, heading, attitude, altitude) and the right screen (MFD) focusing on engine data, mapping, checklists, and everything else. Failed PFD screen In this scenario the screen that is right in front of you (the PFD) has failed. This basically means the screen has gone dark. We simulate that by dimming the screen down to 0% brightness. After darkening the PFD we shot a GPS approach into Rock Hill. When this failure has occured you shift the G1000 into Reversionary mode. That means the info that is normally split across 2 screens is now merged into 1. It actually duplicates the same data on both screens, but since the PFD screen is no longer functioning
Read more

A-10C Standby Compass - Sun Shade

Image
 One of the final items to add to this instrument build (besides the text covers for the lower LEDs) was the sun shade for the AR LED box.  I made this out of thin aluminum sheets , cutting it from a template using some metal sheers .    My template was created by tracing some of the actual artwork from the DCS sim, and then scaling it to the proper size. It turned out ok, not perfect but pretty good.  Primed and painted it and then installed it using 2 of the 4 holes that were already on the LED box 3D print.  I used some heat inserts in those holes to give the screws something to bite, but the holes are really too big for my inserts so had to use some glue to help out.  
Read more